Woman Freed After Nearly 27 Years in Prison Amid Claims Her Murder Trial Lawyer Was Sleeping with Her Sister

Tashiena Combs was convicted in 2000 of first-degree premeditated murder and two weapons charges in connection with the fatal shooting of a woman in 1999
She received a mandatory life sentence on the top charge but a judge vacated her conviction
Combs’ trial attorney concealed that he was also representing her sister — with whom he allegedly had an undisclosed sexual relationship
A Michigan judge has vacated the first-degree murder conviction of a woman who served nearly 27 years of a life sentence, finding she received ineffective counsel, and ordered her immediate release.
Oakland County Circuit Judge Nanci J. Grant granted Tashiena Combs’ motion for relief from judgment, the Michigan Appellate Assigned Counsel System said in a news release Wednesday, Nov. 18.
A jury convicted Combs in 2000 of first-degree premeditated murder, carrying a concealed weapon in a vehicle and possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony. She received a mandatory life sentence for the top charge.
Combs’ trial attorney allegedly concealed that he was also representing her sister — with whom he allegedly had an undisclosed sexual relationship —stemming from the same shooting, according to the news release. The Oakland County Prosecutor’s Office said Combs’ trial attorney never discussed her rights regarding the conflict of interest, as uncovered by the office’s Conviction Integrity Unit.
Oakland County Circuit Court Judge Nanci J. GrantCredit: Oakland County Michigan
That conflict shaped the defense Combs received, according to her appellate attorneys. They allege her trial attorney also kept two key witnesses from testifying to protect her sister’s case. Those witnesses could have supported Combs’ claim of self-defense and called into question whether the murder was premeditated.
Prosecutors acknowledged they could not pursue a first-degree murder charge at a new trial and agreed Combs was entitled to relief, the news release says.
The judge who overturned Combs’ conviction noted in her opinion that Combs has already served more time than the sentencing guidelines would call for on a second-degree murder or voluntary manslaughter charge and is entitled to immediate release.
Jana Mathieu, Combs’ lead appellate attorney, called what happened in her case “unconscionable.”
“Unfortunately, her case is not unique,” Mathieu said in a statement. “With a legal system founded in racism, sexism, and socioeconomic oppression, it is crucial that we do not give up who the system has tried to throw away. It doesn’t matter whether the case is recent or decades old — when a conviction is predicated on a failure of the system, there is a way to dismantle it.”
According to a Michigan Court of Appeals opinion, evidence was presented at trial that Combs obtained a gun and ammunition from her then-boyfriend’s house and had made threats to kill before fatally shooting a woman multiple times in Pontiac, Michigan, in 1999.
Source: Crime
0 Comments